Tale after Tale.
Mystery & crime · Reflective

On Going to Law

By Leo Tolstoy·1911·2 min read

A peasant will sell his last cow to keep appealing a garden dispute whose legal costs already exceed the land’s value.

More details
Settings
The home
Tone
Ironic
Pace
Brisk
Written for
For adults

On Going to Law

  • A Peasant

  • His Wife

  • A Kinswoman

  • Fedia, the peasant’s son, a lad of nineteen

  • Petka, another son, a boy of nine

Father Entering the cottage and taking off his cloak. What beastly weather! I could hardly manage to get home.

Mother And such a long way for you. It must be nearly fifteen miles.

Father Not less than twenty, I can tell you. To his son, Fedia. Take the colt to the stable.

Mother Well, have we won?

Peasant We have not, damn it all. It will never come right.

Kinswoman But what is it all about, cousin? I don’t quite understand.

Peasant It is simply that Averian has taken possession of my vegetable garden and is holding it. And I can’t get at him in the right way.

Wife That lawsuit has been dragging along over a year now.

Kinswoman I know, I know. I remember as far back as Lent, when the matter was before the village court. My man told me it had been settled in your favour.

Peasant That finished it, didn’t it? But Averian appealed to the head of the Zemstvo,[1] and he had the whole business gone into again. I then appealed to the judge and won. That ought to have been the end of it. But it wasn’t. After that he won. Nice sort of judges they are!

Wife What are we to do now?

Peasant I won’t stand his having my property. I will appeal to the higher court, I have already had a talk with a lawyer.

Kinswoman But suppose they take his side in the upper court?

Peasant Then I’ll go to the Supreme Court. I’ll sell my last cow before I’ll give in to that fat hound. I’ll teach him a lesson.

Kinswoman A lot of trouble comes from these trials, a lot of trouble, I declare! And suppose he wins again?

Peasant Then I’ll appeal to the Tsar. Now I had better go out and give the pony some hay. Exit.

Petka Why do they judge like that, some saying Averian is right and some daddy?

Mother Probably because they don’t know who is right themselves.

Petka Then why ask them, if they don’t know?

Mother Because nobody wants to give up his property.

Petka When I grow up, I will do like this: If I have a dispute with somebody, we will cast lots and see who wins. And that will settle it. We always settle it this way with Akulika.

Kinswoman Don’t you think, cousin, that is quite a good way? One sin less, anyhow.

Mother Quite so. What a lot we have spent on that trial! More than the whole vegetable garden is worth. Oh, it is a sin, a great sin!

Notes

  1. County council.

    Back to reference 1

How did it stay with you?

Rate On Going to Law, from 1 to 10.

Choose a number, then save your rating.

A small reflection before the next story.

More details
Settings
The home
Tone
Ironic
Pace
Brisk
Written for
For adults
When you’re ready

Stay a little longer.

More by Leo Tolstoy

Explore Leo Tolstoy →

Similar stories

Your own little corner

Welcome back.
Make yourself at home.

Keep your place, save stories for later, and remember the ones you loved.


By continuing, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.