On the Criminal Court
Children trace an unjust sentence up the chain of authority and ask who judges the judge when even the highest ruler can be wrong.
More details
- Themes
- Law & justice · Bureaucracy · Faith & doubt
- Tone
- Ironic
- Style
- Conversational
- Pace
- Brisk
- Written for
- For adults
- Craft
- Told in dialogue
On the Criminal Court
-
Children: Grishka, Semka, Jishka
Jishka Serves him right. Why did he make his way into another person’s corn loft? When he is put in prison that will teach him not to do it another time.
Semka Of course if he has really done it. But old Mikita said Mitrofan was run into prison without being guilty.
Jishka Without being guilty? And won’t anything happen to the man who judged him falsely?
Grishka Well, they won’t pat him on the head for it, of course. If he hasn’t judged according to law he will be punished too.
Semka Who will punish him?
Jishka Those above him.
Semka Who are above him?
Grishka His superiors.
Jishka And if the superiors also make a mistake?
Grishka There are higher powers above them, and they will be punished by these. That’s what the Tsar is for.
Jishka But if the Tsar judges wrong, who is going to punish him?
Grishka Who? Why do you ask that? Don’t you know?
Semka God will punish him.
Jishka God will also punish him who stole the corn from the loft. Then why not leave it to God to punish those who are guilty? He will not judge wrong.
Grishka It’s clear that that is not possible.
Jishka Why not?
Grishka Because …