On War
Three children debate borders, armies, and patriotism until the youngest asks why nations must remain separate at all.
More details
- Themes
- War & peace · Identity
- Tone
- Ironic
- Style
- Conversational
- Pace
- Brisk
- Written for
- For adults
- Craft
- Told in dialogue
On War
-
Karlchen Schmidt, nine years
-
Petia Orlov, ten years
-
Masha Orlov, eight years
Karlchen … Because we Prussians will not allow Russia to rob us of our land.
Petia But we say this land belongs to us; we conquered it first.
Masha To whom? Is it ours?
Petia You are a child, and you don’t understand. “To us” means to our state.
Karlchen It is this way; some belong to one state and some to another.
Masha What do I belong to?
Petia You belong to Russia, like the rest of us.
Masha And if I don’t want to?
Petia It doesn’t matter whether you want to or not. You are Russian all the same. Every nation has its Tsar, its King.
Karlchen Interrupting. And a parliament.
Petia Each state has its army, each state raises taxes.
Masha But why must each state stand by itself?
Petia What a silly question! Because each state is a separate one.
Masha But why must it exist apart?
Petia Can’t you understand? Because everybody loves his own country.
Masha I don’t understand why they must be separate from the rest. Wouldn’t it be better if they all kept together?
Petia To keep together is all right when you play games. But this is no game: it is a very serious matter.
Masha I don’t understand.
Karlchen You will when you grow up.
Masha Then I don’t want to grow up.
Petia Such a tiny girl, and obstinate already, just like all of them.